Why research alone is not enough to create value?
Research is fundamental for expanding knowledge, driving innovation, and addressing societal challenges (Suomen Akatemia, n.d.; UNIFI, 2026). Research is often driven by the pursuit of new knowledge, the exploration of emerging ideas, or the development of novel technologies and discoveries. While scientific excellence and discussion are essential, these are not enough alone.
Research should generate benefits beyond academia and contribute to society through practical applications and innovation. Such value is most effectively created when research addresses genuine societal needs and engages relevant stakeholders throughout the research and innovation process (UK Research and Innovation, 2026; UK Research and Innovation, 2022). While generating new knowledge remains a core objective, research becomes more impactful when its results can be understood, adopted, and applied in practice. Therefore, researchers should also consider how research results can be transferred to society and how their value can be communicated to potential users and organisations.
Researchers Talk About the Drill, Users Want the Hole
In order to address genuine needs and create meaningful impact, researchers must look beyond the scientific novelty of their work and consider how its outcomes can be applied in practice. Yet, when asked about the benefits of a new technology, product, or solution, researchers often focus on the technology itself, describing scientific principles, technical features, methods, algorithms, or research breakthroughs. However, people do not want a description of the technology of a drill; they want a hole in the wall and ultimately a picture hanging on it. What matters is not the tool itself, but the outcome, benefit, or problem it helps solve. Users, companies, and investors are therefore usually interested in different questions: What problem does this solve? How does it improve my work, my business, or my life? When research results are communicated primarily through technical language, their value may remain abstract and difficult for non-experts to recognise. It should also be noted that understanding users may open new avenues for research, innovation, and discovery.
This tendency is entirely understandable. Researchers are traditionally trained to generate and advance scientific knowledge within their field, while competencies related to stakeholder engagement, user understanding, research translation, and societal impact often receive less attention in academic training and incentive systems (Scott et al., 2019; Grant, 2021; Maurer et al., 2022). As a consequence, the focus is often placed on scientific and technical excellence rather than on the concrete value that research outcomes may create for users and society. Without regular interaction with users and stakeholders, or when they are involved only at later stages, assumptions about their needs and expectations may be based on indirect information rather than first-hand understanding. This can make it more difficult to identify genuine needs, improve the relevance of research, and maximise its societal impact.
To bridge this gap, researchers need approaches that help them better understand users, their needs, and the contexts in which research outcomes may be applied. One such approach is Design Thinking, which encourages a shift from technology-centred thinking to user-centred thinking.
From Technology to People: How Design Thinking Helps Researchers Create Meaningful Innovation
Technology alone rarely creates impact. Impact emerges when research and innovation address real user and societal needs. Design Thinking provides methods to identify those needs and translate research into solutions that people are willing and able to use. Design Thinking is a human-centred approach to innovation and problem solving that combines empathy, multidisciplinary collaboration, experimentation, visualisation, and iterative learning. Rather than focusing solely on technology or scientific advancement, it seeks to understand users’ needs and translate these insights into meaningful solutions. It is particularly valuable for addressing complex and uncertain challenges where both the problem and the solution are not yet fully understood. (Brown, 2008).
Thus, Design Thinking encourages researchers to consider who will use their innovation, what value it creates, and how it addresses real-world challenges. In doing so, it also adds value to the research process itself by supporting the refinement, development, and practical application of research outcomes. Design Thinking can therefore strengthen both the impact of research and the effective utilisation of its results. The most essential benefits of Design Thinking to research are:
Firstly, Design Thinking helps researchers understand users and their needs through empathy, stakeholder engagement, and testing. This reduces assumptions and helps identify genuine challenges while potentially revealing new opportunities for research and innovation.
Secondly, Design Thinking can help identify new research questions and opportunities. Working with users often reveals overlooked needs and perspectives leading to more relevant research topics, questions, innovative solutions, user orientation, and even entirely new research directions.
Thirdly, Design Thinking helps bridge the gap between research and practice by bringing together users and other stakeholders to better understand real-world needs and challenges. It provides a common framework and language for collaboration, increasing the likelihood that research outcomes will be translated into practical applications, innovations, and societal value.
Fourthly, Design Thinking supports the feasibility and viability of research outcomes by enabling early testing with users. This helps validate assumptions, refine solutions, and identify challenges before significant resources are invested. As a result, research outcomes are often more relevant, practical, and cost-effective.
Finally, Design Thinking can strengthen research impact by helping research address genuine needs and create value for users and stakeholders. This increases the likelihood that research outcomes will be adopted, implemented, scaled, and translated into societal benefits.
Experiences from the APPROACH Project
The APPROACH project aimed to strengthen research and innovation capacity in solar energy harvesting technologies by developing the skills and capabilities of early-career researchers in the field (APPROACH Project, n.d.). Among the various training topics introduced was Design Thinking, which supports the translation of research into practical and impactful outcomes.
Design Thinking was introduced through both workshops and secondments which are temporary periods of work in a partner organisation that support the exchange of expertise. While the workshops provided a general overview, the secondments at Vaasa University of Applied Sciences (VAMK) offered a deeper introduction to Design Thinking including user-centredness and creativity. During the secondments, participants explored several Design Thinking methods, including Personas, SCAMPER, and the 5 Whys technique. These tools encouraged researchers to look beyond technical aspects and consider user needs and real-world contexts.
The 5 Whys tool was used to identify the root causes of problems, exploring justifications for products and reasons for users to become interested in or adopt a solution. Rather than jumping to immediate solutions, the tool helped uncover new perspectives and opportunities. Learning about user orientation was also supported by the Persona tool. Different technical solutions and their potential applications were reflected against the created personas, revealing diverse needs, interests, and ways of engaging with different user groups. User orientation was also explored through usability and accessibility. This provided hands-on insights into how people perceive solutions and how they can be designed so that users can, want to, and are able to use them. The SCAMPER tool instead promoted creativity and divergent thinking, while also helping participants identify new opportunities in product and service development. The workshops focused on problem spotting and solution creation.
How Design Thinking Expanded Researchers’ Perspectives
The secondments and workshops demonstrated that even a limited introduction to Design Thinking tools can significantly broaden researchers’ perspectives on innovation and impact. Participants identified new ideas, opportunities, and application areas that brought research outcomes closer to the needs of end users. The activities also increased participants’ understanding of different user groups and stakeholder needs, while highlighting new opportunities for collaboration across sectors and value chains. In some cases, this led to the identification of potential partners and forms of collaboration that had not previously been considered.
Another important outcome was a greater emphasis on understanding the root causes of challenges before developing solutions. Rather than seeking the quickest answer, participants learned to explore underlying needs and problems first, resulting in more appropriate and user-oriented solutions.
In addition, activities related to usability and accessibility increased awareness of how people perceive solutions, websites, and communication materials. Participants gained a better understanding of how usability and accessibility influence user experience, stakeholder engagement, and organisational image, while helping to avoid common pitfalls in communication and implementation.
The visual and interactive nature of Design Thinking supported learning and helped participants better internalise new concepts and approaches, particularly in face-to-face sessions where collaborative and visual methods encouraged deeper engagement and understanding.
Conclusions and recommendations
Scientific excellence alone does not guarantee societal impact. To create value, researchers must understand who will use their results, what needs they address, and how the results can be applied in practice. The experiences from the APPROACH project suggest that Design Thinking can help researchers identify user needs, uncover innovation opportunities, and strengthen pathways from research to impact. Even a small set of tools, such as Personas and the 5 Whys, can broaden perspectives, support collaboration, and improve the relevance of research outcomes.
Importantly, Design Thinking is best learned through practical and interactive activities rather than through theory alone. Based on these experiences, we recommend integrating user-centred approaches and selected Design Thinking tools into researcher training, particularly in technology-intensive fields. Better understanding of users and stakeholders can help bridge the gap between research and practice and increase societal impact.
Ultimately, research creates the greatest impact when knowledge is translated into solutions that benefit people, organisations, and society.
PROJECT INFORMATION
APPROACH (101120397), a project funded by the European Union Horizon Programme, aims to promote the employability and careers of researchers in the solar energy harvesting sector, with a particular focus on competences needed in business, internal entrepreneurship, project and innovation skills, and exploitability of research results. https://euproject-approach.eu
DISCLAIMER: This project receives funding from the European Commission’s Horizon Europe Research Programme under Grant Agreement Number 101120397.



